If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Desktop or workstation video card?
We need to get a new video card for my wife's PC and don't know
whether to chose a desktop or workstation video card. She has a PCI-16x (I don't think 2.0) and uses it for AfterEffects, Lightwave, and other graphic and video editing software, pretty much no games (aside from MSN type games). She wants to run two monitors. The main problem is our budget of $250. The good workstation cards I've seen are the $450 Quadro cards. For less than $250, should we still get a workstation card or would a quality desktop card work well for her needs? If so, any chipset or pixel pipes or anything to suggest? Thanks for any feedback! Liam |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Desktop or workstation video card?
Mechphisto wrote:
We need to get a new video card for my wife's PC and don't know whether to chose a desktop or workstation video card. She has a PCI-16x (I don't think 2.0) and uses it for AfterEffects, Lightwave, and other graphic and video editing software, pretty much no games (aside from MSN type games). She wants to run two monitors. The main problem is our budget of $250. The good workstation cards I've seen are the $450 Quadro cards. For less than $250, should we still get a workstation card or would a quality desktop card work well for her needs? If so, any chipset or pixel pipes or anything to suggest? Thanks for any feedback! Liam The major difference between "workstation video cards" and desktop cards is certification and drivers that conform to some established CAD standards. IIRC, some programs will interrogate the video card to see if it meets the "approved" list of "workstation video cards". Some users in the past have reported that they "converted" various Nvidea vidcards to Quadro cards (as far as reporting as Quadro hardware to software that does that. It was done by flashing the card with a relevant Quadro flash for the basic card family involved. http://www.google.com/search?q=flashing+to+Quadro&sourceid=navclient-ff&ie=UTF-8&rlz=1B3GGGL_enUS272US273 You may want to peruse the "alt.comp.periphs.videocards" newsgroups. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Desktop or workstation video card?
In article , nobody
says... Mechphisto wrote: We need to get a new video card for my wife's PC and don't know whether to chose a desktop or workstation video card. She has a PCI-16x (I don't think 2.0) and uses it for AfterEffects, Lightwave, and other graphic and video editing software, pretty much no games (aside from MSN type games). She wants to run two monitors. The main problem is our budget of $250. The good workstation cards I've seen are the $450 Quadro cards. For less than $250, should we still get a workstation card or would a quality desktop card work well for her needs? If so, any chipset or pixel pipes or anything to suggest? Thanks for any feedback! Liam The major difference between "workstation video cards" and desktop cards is certification and drivers that conform to some established CAD standards. IIRC, some programs will interrogate the video card to see if it meets the "approved" list of "workstation video cards". Err, no. Workstation cards do CAD etc WAY faster than a desktop card designed for 3D gaming. -- Conor I only please one person per day. Today is not your day. Tomorrow isn't looking good either. - Scott Adams |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Desktop or workstation video card?
On May 11, 3:37*pm, Conor wrote:
In article , nobody says... Mechphisto wrote: We need to get a new video card for my wife's PC and don't know whether to chose a desktop or workstation video card. She has a PCI-16x (I don't think 2.0) and uses it for AfterEffects, Lightwave, and other graphic and video editing software, pretty much no games (aside from MSN type games). She wants to run two monitors. The main problem is our budget of $250. The good workstation cards I've seen are the $450 Quadro cards. For less than $250, should we still get a workstation card or would a quality desktop card work well for her needs? If so, any chipset or pixel pipes or anything to suggest? Thanks for any feedback! Liam The major difference between "workstation video cards" and desktop cards * is certification and drivers that conform to some established CAD standards. IIRC, some programs will interrogate the video card to see if it meets the "approved" list of "workstation video cards". Err, no. Workstation cards do CAD etc WAY faster than a desktop card designed for 3D gaming. -- Conor I only please one person per day. Today is not your day. Tomorrow isn't looking good either. - Scott Adams So, in your opinion, in the service of AfterEffect, Lightwave, etc., if I just had $250 to spend, would I be better off getting a low end workstation card or a mid range desktop? |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Desktop or workstation video card?
* nobody :
The major difference between "workstation video cards" and desktop cards is certification Yes. and drivers that conform to some established CAD standards. No. "Quadro drivers" are generic ForceWare drivers that like the cards have been certified for certain application. "Quadro drivers" work fine with Geforce and vice versa. With AMD, the "FireGL driver" is a generic Catalyst driver with modified installation routine and a different OpenGL part (optimized for quality and not for performance). The D3D part is identical. IIRC, some programs will interrogate the video card to see if it meets the "approved" list of "workstation video cards". For example? I have never seen any application that does that. Most professional programs run just fine with Geforce and Radeon cards. Some users in the past have reported that they "converted" various Nvidea Nvid_i_a vidcards to Quadro cards (as far as reporting as Quadro hardware to software that does that. It was done by flashing the card with a relevant Quadro flash for the basic card family involved. Nope. The hardware ID of Geforce and Quadro is different which means on older cards you had to solder (moving some SMD resistors) and on newer cards (GF4 and above) it isn't possible any more. However, what is possible is to a) either modify the gfx driver to recognize a Geforce as Quadro (and thus enabling all the Quadro stuff) or b) using RivaTuner or other tools to make the gfx driver think your card is a Quadro. Benjamin |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Desktop or workstation video card?
* Mechphisto:
So, in your opinion, in the service of AfterEffect, Lightwave, etc., if I just had $250 to spend, would I be better off getting a low end workstation card or a mid range desktop? Does your wife use AfterEffects and Lightwave for a living and thus is dependent on the ISV support? Then get a certified board like PNY Quadro FX or ATI/AMD FireGL (I'd get a FireGL as they often are cheaper than comparable Quadro cards). If your wife does it as hobby then get a Geforce desktop card. It will do as good as the professional board. Benjamin |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Desktop or workstation video card?
On May 11, 4:19*pm, Benjamin Gawert wrote:
* Mechphisto: So, in your opinion, in the service of AfterEffect, Lightwave, etc., if I just had $250 to spend, would I be better off getting a low end workstation card or a mid range desktop? Does your wife use AfterEffects and Lightwave for a living and thus is dependent on the ISV support? Then get a certified board like PNY Quadro FX or ATI/AMD FireGL (I'd get a FireGL as they often are cheaper than comparable Quadro cards). If your wife does it as hobby then get a Geforce desktop card. It will do as good as the professional board. Benjamin If as good, why not just the GeForce? Unfortunately, she doesn't currently have a job in graphics, but is trying to build up her portfolio by doing small projects for churches and whatnot so she CAN get a job doing it for a living. Thanks for the replies. Liam |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Desktop or workstation video card?
* Mechphisto:
If as good, why not just the GeForce? Because most ISVs only provide support for their software if used with certified hardware. However, more and more ISVs now also certify consumer gfx cards (Geforce and Radeon) with their products. Benjamin |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Desktop or workstation video card?
In article be1d062e-205d-4f57-83b2-47d8c09df0f4
@r36g2000vbr.googlegroups.com, Mechphisto says... So, in your opinion, in the service of AfterEffect, Lightwave, etc., if I just had $250 to spend, would I be better off getting a low end workstation card or a mid range desktop? Yes. Tomshardware did some benchmarking a while back and gaming cards fared poorly in the apps you mention. Workstation cards are optimised for such applications as are the drivers. -- Conor I only please one person per day. Today is not your day. Tomorrow isn't looking good either. - Scott Adams |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Desktop or workstation video card?
On May 12, 3:57*am, Conor wrote:
In article be1d062e-205d-4f57-83b2-47d8c09df0f4 @r36g2000vbr.googlegroups.com, Mechphisto says... So, in your opinion, in the service of AfterEffect, Lightwave, etc., if I just had $250 to spend, would I be better off getting a low end workstation card or a mid range desktop? Yes. Tomshardware did some benchmarking a while back and gaming cards fared poorly in the apps you mention. Workstation cards are optimised for such applications as are the drivers. So, in my price range are these two cards: desktop: GeForce GTX 260 Core 216 896MB http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814130434 and workstation: FireGL V3600 256MB 128-bit http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814195048 On specs, the GeForce appears to not just blow the workstation card away but obliterate it. Yet, the workstation card is theortetically a better performer for, say, AfterEffects? Thanks for advice and opinions. |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Desktop or workstation video card? | Mechphisto | Nvidia Videocards | 3 | May 12th 09 08:32 PM |
What two head video card can play High Definition video on a secondary monitor in the extended desktop mode? | Dima[_2_] | Homebuilt PC's | 18 | July 2nd 07 07:11 AM |
I got a little problem with my video card in 3d mode and on my desktop... | DDC | Ati Videocards | 4 | May 28th 06 03:52 PM |
Workstation or desktop? | Dave Smith | General | 0 | August 24th 03 06:15 AM |