HAS *ANYBODY* out there seen this PROBLEM with ASUS A7N8X-E Deluxe????

Hello,

I have a new ASUS A7N8X-E motherboard which shows fan RPM as ZERO
except for the case that the fan is actually being POWERED from the +12V
terminal of the three-pin fan header. Now this is not a problem for the chassis
fan; but it IS an issue with the Power Supply Fan (draws power internally
from the PS) and the CPU fan which is a high-performance model that exceeds
the load capacity available from the fan header (350mA ~ 740mA).

Both the PS and CPU fans provide a fan speed sense connector for the purpose
of RPM monitoring. The PS has wires for both ground and RPM sense. The CPU
fan has only a wire for the RPM sense. Until I ran across this board, the RPM of
both of these could be read out without difficulty despite the fact that they drew
power from another source.

I flashed the board to the LATEST BIOS and the problem still persists. Anybody
know of a way to get around this problem? What would happen if I were to put some
kind of artificial load on the +12V fan header output? Would the ground line also have
to be connected?

*** THESE THINGS USED TO WORK JUST FINE "AS IS" IN THE PAST!!! ***


TO ASUS:
-----------------------
Is this a design flaw or was it done on purpose? Obviously, I MUST be able to
monitor these CRITICAL fans - otherwise I could fry an expensive PS and CPU should
a fan go down and I'd not get any alarm (because I'd have to disable it in order to run
with this board). Yes, over-temp should catch the CPU but by then it may be too late!!
I don't know what protection the PS has built into it (an Antec True 430-watt).


=====
You may send e-mail if you wish provided it is NOT SPAM. To decode my valid
E-mail address, you will need to remove the NOSPAM. and the 666. I had
to get complicated as spammers are now doing the obvious removal of the word
"NOSPAM" to compile their lists of e-mails...

- G.L. Cross

G.L. Cross - typed:
Hello,

I have a new ASUS A7N8X-E motherboard which shows fan RPM as ZERO
except for the case that the fan is actually being POWERED from the
+12V
terminal of the three-pin fan header. Now this is not a problem for
the chassis
fan; but it IS an issue with the Power Supply Fan (draws power
internally
from the PS) and the CPU fan which is a high-performance model that
exceeds
the load capacity available from the fan header (350mA ~ 740mA).

Both the PS and CPU fans provide a fan speed sense connector for the
purpose
of RPM monitoring. The PS has wires for both ground and RPM sense.
The CPU
fan has only a wire for the RPM sense. Until I ran across this board,
the RPM of
both of these could be read out without difficulty despite the fact
that they drew power from another source.

I flashed the board to the LATEST BIOS and the problem still
persists. Anybody
know of a way to get around this problem? What would happen if I were
to put some
kind of artificial load on the +12V fan header output? Would the
ground line also have to be connected?

Snipped

Yup - seeing the same problem on my new A7N8X-E Deluxe. Neither my CPU
or PSU fan's speed is reported in the Bios & MBM5 either shows zero or
unrealistically high revs. Both these fans were reported correctly on my
retired A7V266-E. Flashed from 1011 to 1012E - no difference.

You may get a response from Asus but don't hold your breath! It could be
a hardware fault common to both our boards of course. You should not
need any load on the PSU or CPU fan header, IIRC. The ground return back
to the PSU is basically there to give a noise free signal & probably
should be OK without it at such low frequencies. Interesting that your
chassis works - my PSU fan is the same as yours but my CPU fan is
powered by the header via a Zalman Fan Mate. Try attaching your chassis
fan to the CPU header to see what happens.

As an aside, why the hell do so many m/bs have S3 power management mode
off as a default where enabling it after OS installation usually means
the fans will still run (S2)?

--
The map is not the territory

"Let them eat beef" wrote in message ...
G.L. Cross - typed:

.... snipped...

Interesting that your
chassis works - my PSU fan is the same as yours but my CPU fan is
powered by the header via a Zalman Fan Mate. Try attaching your chassis
fan to the CPU header to see what happens.

Did that, when I attach the chassis fan (which is powered from the header +12V supply),
I get correct RPM at all three locations: Chassis, CPU, and PSU. The common thread
I found is that you will not get a RPM reading if you power the fan from ANY SOURCE
other than the fan header it is connected to - despite proper connection of the speed-sense
line to the MB header...

Also one strange thing: with a DC Voltmeter and no fan connected to one of the headers,
I measure the correct +12V center pin to ground. But strange is that I measure a constant
+5V between the "rotation" pin and ground. I thought the fan sent a pulse once per revolution
AS INPUT to the "rotation" terminal (why is there a voltage on it when there is no fan???).


- Gordon

On Tue, 28 Sep 2004 16:13:35 -0500, "G.L. Cross"
wrote:

"Let them eat beef" wrote in message ...
G.L. Cross - typed:

... snipped...

Interesting that your
chassis works - my PSU fan is the same as yours but my CPU fan is
powered by the header via a Zalman Fan Mate. Try attaching your chassis
fan to the CPU header to see what happens.

Did that, when I attach the chassis fan (which is powered from the header +12V supply),
I get correct RPM at all three locations: Chassis, CPU, and PSU. The common thread
I found is that you will not get a RPM reading if you power the fan from ANY SOURCE
other than the fan header it is connected to - despite proper connection of the speed-sense
line to the MB header...

Also one strange thing: with a DC Voltmeter and no fan connected to one of the headers,
I measure the correct +12V center pin to ground. But strange is that I measure a constant
+5V between the "rotation" pin and ground. I thought the fan sent a pulse once per revolution
AS INPUT to the "rotation" terminal (why is there a voltage on it when there is no fan???).


Did you research the board before you bought it?
Does it have the speadfan feature?
Did you research this or just assume it would make no
difference in your planned deviation from normal use?

You can't return a board based on malfunction, when it isn't
malfunctioning. Most people like speedfan... if you don't,
buy a board with no fan speed control integral to it.

In article , DaveyB
wrote:

On Tue, 28 Sep 2004 21:58:03 GMT, kony wrote:

Also one strange thing: with a DC Voltmeter and no fan connected to
one of the headers,
I measure the correct +12V center pin to ground. But strange is that I
measure a constant
+5V between the "rotation" pin and ground. I thought the fan sent a
pulse once per revolution
AS INPUT to the "rotation" terminal (why is there a voltage on it when
there is no fan???).


I'm taking an educated guess at this one concerning the fan sensor.
The +5v on the rotation pin has very little current. When the fan
sends a pulse it grounds the +5v on the rotation pin and the
speed sensor on the MB sees this transition to 0v as a pulse. It's
called "inverted logic", it's very common in digital circuits. The
ATX power supply uses this logic it to switch on - one of the
pins on the connector block sits at +5v - again with very little
current. To switch the supply on the PC grounds this pin and holds
it at 0v. If you ever look at a pinout of a memory DIMM, PCI
Bus, parallel printer port or anything digital you'll come across
some pin labels where the label has a line above it. That's inverted
logic - the signal is sent by grounding the pin.

Davey

It is also referred to as an open collector interface, or alternately,
a wire-OR interface. Normal logic involves two transistors, working
as a push pull pair. Open collector logic replaces the upper transistor
with a pull up resistor to +V. When the lower transistor turns on,
the signal on the end of the pullup resistor goes to zero volts.
When the transistor turns off, the pullup resistor eventually
restores the signal to +V volts. That is a logic 1 level. (When more
than one transistor is connected to the resistor, you get an OR
logic gate capability, as either one transistor OR the other can
pull the line to logic 0.)

Finding voltage on that pin is normal, and the voltage can be
anywhere between 5 and 12V, depending on the conditioning network
used on the motherboard. Some application notes connect the resistor
to +12V, and then follow the output with an attenuation network, to
get the voltage down to levels suitable for interfacing to logic
devices. Other application notes use the simpler direct pullup to
+5V, with no other resistors in the circuit.

HTH,
Paul

"G.L. Cross" wrote in
:


Did that, when I attach the chassis fan (which is powered from the
header +12V supply), I get correct RPM at all three locations:
Chassis, CPU, and PSU. The common thread I found is that you will not
get a RPM reading if you power the fan from ANY SOURCE other than the
fan header it is connected to - despite proper connection of the
speed-sense line to the MB header...

Try connecting the ground as well.


Also one strange thing: with a DC Voltmeter and no fan connected to
one of the headers, I measure the correct +12V center pin to ground.
But strange is that I measure a constant +5V between the "rotation"
pin and ground. I thought the fan sent a pulse once per revolution AS
INPUT to the "rotation" terminal (why is there a voltage on it when
there is no fan???).

Connecting a DMM to digital signal is not gonna work. You need an o-scope
to what on that signal. Plus, that may just be normal operation when the
fan is not connected.