A computer components & hardware forum. HardwareBanter

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » HardwareBanter forum » System Manufacturers & Vendors » Dell Computers
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

Memory: Does it matter if big DDRs are firsr or second?



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #11  
Old December 19th 10, 11:23 PM posted to alt.comp.hardware,alt.sys.pc-clone.dell
Tony Harding[_5_]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 105
Default Memory: Does it matter if big DDRs are firsr or second?

On 12/17/10 19:07, mm wrote:
On Wed, 15 Dec 2010 22:17:24 -0500, Ben
wrote:

On 12/15/2010 9:52 PM, mm wrote:
Memory: Does it matter if big DDRs are firsr or second?

Posted to alt.comp.hardware and alt.sys.pc-clone.dell, since the
computer is a Dell and I started the topic in that group, but have
broader questions now.


I have two 512M and two 1G DDR[1]s and they are the same speed PC2700,
the same 333, the same CL 2.5, the same non-ECC and assume everything
else the same except the brand and size.

Does it make a difference if the big pair goes in the first pair of
slots, or if the small pair does???

Is this true for DDR2 and DDR3 also?


Just to be perfectly clear, if you are talking about Dell Precision 360,
Dimension 4600, Optiplex GX270, or Dimension 8300,


It was meant as a general question.

I'm 99% sure I've read that *faster* memory should go in the first
pair of slots, and that makes sense so that one should use the faster
memory most of the time.

But here the speed is the same, only the *size* is different, so does
it matter which one is first?

two memory slots have
black DIMM clips and two have white clips. A matched pair has to go in
a pair of DIMM slots with the same color of clips.


Yes, thanks, the computer I'm working on now is a Dell 4600 and the
manual made that clear.

As a rule, I install
the larger capacity memory in the "first" pair of slots.


But is that a personal practice, or maybe a habit left over from fast
vs. slow memory, or is it really based on some benchmark testing or
recommended by engineers or so forth?


IIRC (from an admittedly failing memory), when you mix faster & slower
DIMMs, *all* memory runs at the slower speed (tends to keep things in
sync internally - if you were moving data from faster to slower memory
and tried to use the 2 different speeds, fun might ensue g).
  #12  
Old December 19th 10, 11:40 PM posted to alt.comp.hardware,alt.sys.pc-clone.dell
mm
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 459
Default Memory: Does it matter if big DDRs are firsr or second?

On Sun, 19 Dec 2010 11:53:21 -0500, Ben Myers
wrote:

On 12/17/2010 10:52 PM, mm wrote:
On Fri, 17 Dec 2010 19:07:59 -0800, wrote:

mm wrote:
On Wed, 15 Dec 2010 22:17:24 -0500, Ben
wrote:

On 12/15/2010 9:52 PM, mm wrote:
Memory: Does it matter if big DDRs are firsr or second?

Posted to alt.comp.hardware and alt.sys.pc-clone.dell, since the
computer is a Dell and I started the topic in that group, but have
broader questions now.


I have two 512M and two 1G DDR[1]s and they are the same speed PC2700,
the same 333, the same CL 2.5, the same non-ECC and assume everything
else the same except the brand and size.

Does it make a difference if the big pair goes in the first pair of
slots, or if the small pair does???

Is this true for DDR2 and DDR3 also?
Just to be perfectly clear, if you are talking about Dell Precision 360,
Dimension 4600, Optiplex GX270, or Dimension 8300,

It was meant as a general question.

I'm 99% sure I've read that *faster* memory should go in the first
pair of slots, and that makes sense so that one should use the faster
memory most of the time.

How did you determine that?


I didn't determine it. "I'm 99% sure that I read it." It makes
sense, to me, and a reason it makes sense would be so that it used
faster memory more often that way.

The first memory allocated may or may not
be from any particular address space and the area most accessed may or may
not be related to the address space assigned to that function? yes? no?


I don't know. You end your sentence with a question mark, so I guess
you're not saying one way or the other.

My concentration was on whether large DIMMs should be first or not.

If the answer to your question means that it doesn't matter if faster
DIMMs are first, then it likely doesn't matter if large DIMMs are
first.



But here the speed is the same, only the *size* is different, so does
it matter which one is first?

two memory slots have
black DIMM clips and two have white clips. A matched pair has to go in
a pair of DIMM slots with the same color of clips.

Yes, thanks, the computer I'm working on now is a Dell 4600 and the
manual made that clear.

As a rule, I install
the larger capacity memory in the "first" pair of slots.

But is that a personal practice, or maybe a habit left over from fast
vs. slow memory, or is it really based on some benchmark testing or
recommended by engineers or so forth?

Which is the
"first" pair of slots? Usually the one nearest to the CPU and its mate
with the same color of clips. But when in doubt, read the owner's
manual. Same for DDR2 and DDR3.

These boards all have Intel 865 or 875 chipsets, which dictate the
memory configuration rules.

Way back when I worked in mainframe software development, we and tech
support used to write "RTFB" responses, telling customers the answers to
their questions or solutions to their problems and telling them to read
the ^^&&*(_* book, where the answer could be found... Ben Myers

The Dell owners manual didn't go into such detail.

Thanks again.



It doesn't matter if faster DIMMs are first. See my other response. It
MAY matter if large DIMMs are first. Again, a read of the owner's
manual or the chipset spec will tell if it does matter... Ben Myers


Okay. Thanks again. For all your help, and thanks to others who
replies.
  #13  
Old December 20th 10, 04:47 AM posted to alt.comp.hardware,alt.sys.pc-clone.dell
Ben Myers[_2_]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,607
Default Memory: Does it matter if big DDRs are firsr or second?

On 12/19/2010 1:07 PM, Bob Villa wrote:
On Dec 19, 10:50 am, Ben wrote:
On 12/17/2010 7:07 PM, mm wrote:



On Wed, 15 Dec 2010 22:17:24 -0500, Ben
wrote:


On 12/15/2010 9:52 PM, mm wrote:
Memory: Does it matter if big DDRs are firsr or second?


Posted to alt.comp.hardware and alt.sys.pc-clone.dell, since the
computer is a Dell and I started the topic in that group, but have
broader questions now.


I have two 512M and two 1G DDR[1]s and they are the same speed PC2700,
the same 333, the same CL 2.5, the same non-ECC and assume everything
else the same except the brand and size.


Does it make a difference if the big pair goes in the first pair of
slots, or if the small pair does???


Is this true for DDR2 and DDR3 also?


Just to be perfectly clear, if you are talking about Dell Precision 360,
Dimension 4600, Optiplex GX270, or Dimension 8300,


It was meant as a general question.


I'm 99% sure I've read that *faster* memory should go in the first
pair of slots, and that makes sense so that one should use the faster
memory most of the time.


But here the speed is the same, only the *size* is different, so does
it matter which one is first?


two memory slots have
black DIMM clips and two have white clips. A matched pair has to go in
a pair of DIMM slots with the same color of clips.


Yes, thanks, the computer I'm working on now is a Dell 4600 and the
manual made that clear.


As a rule, I install
the larger capacity memory in the "first" pair of slots.


But is that a personal practice, or maybe a habit left over from fast
vs. slow memory, or is it really based on some benchmark testing or
recommended by engineers or so forth?


Which is the
"first" pair of slots? Usually the one nearest to the CPU and its mate
with the same color of clips. But when in doubt, read the owner's
manual. Same for DDR2 and DDR3.


These boards all have Intel 865 or 875 chipsets, which dictate the
memory configuration rules.


Way back when I worked in mainframe software development, we and tech
support used to write "RTFB" responses, telling customers the answers to
their questions or solutions to their problems and telling them to read
the ^^&&*(_* book, where the answer could be found... Ben Myers


The Dell owners manual didn't go into such detail.


Thanks again.


There is no difference whatsoever placing faster memory in the first
DIMM slots or the second ones. "Faster" memory is rated to run at a
faster speed than slower memory, but it can and does also run at slower
speeds.

The speed at which memory operates is dictated by the motherboard and
CPU, not by the memory itself which is a passive component. For
example, if you put PC3200 memory in a system with a CPU operating with
a 533MHz front side bus (e.g. the hot-running 3.06 GHz P4), the memory
operates at the lower PC2100 speed... Ben Myers


Ben, wouldn't that lower speed instance be PC2700?


Not in the example I used. PC2100 runs at 266MHz speed, exactly half of
533MHz. Because the memory is double data rate (DDR) each clock
supplies two fetches of data, one from each of the dual channels,
assuming that the memory is installed to allow dual channel operation.

But if you install PC2700 in a system with a CPU running with 800MHz
front side bus, the 865 or 875 chipset mediates the difference between
the PC2700 speed and the FSB. So the slower memory runs OK with the
faster CPU... Ben Myers

  #14  
Old December 20th 10, 04:48 AM posted to alt.comp.hardware,alt.sys.pc-clone.dell
Ben Myers[_2_]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,607
Default Memory: Does it matter if big DDRs are firsr or second?

On 12/19/2010 5:23 PM, Tony Harding wrote:
On 12/17/10 19:07, mm wrote:
On Wed, 15 Dec 2010 22:17:24 -0500, Ben
wrote:

On 12/15/2010 9:52 PM, mm wrote:
Memory: Does it matter if big DDRs are firsr or second?

Posted to alt.comp.hardware and alt.sys.pc-clone.dell, since the
computer is a Dell and I started the topic in that group, but have
broader questions now.


I have two 512M and two 1G DDR[1]s and they are the same speed PC2700,
the same 333, the same CL 2.5, the same non-ECC and assume everything
else the same except the brand and size.

Does it make a difference if the big pair goes in the first pair of
slots, or if the small pair does???

Is this true for DDR2 and DDR3 also?

Just to be perfectly clear, if you are talking about Dell Precision 360,
Dimension 4600, Optiplex GX270, or Dimension 8300,


It was meant as a general question.

I'm 99% sure I've read that *faster* memory should go in the first
pair of slots, and that makes sense so that one should use the faster
memory most of the time.

But here the speed is the same, only the *size* is different, so does
it matter which one is first?

two memory slots have
black DIMM clips and two have white clips. A matched pair has to go in
a pair of DIMM slots with the same color of clips.


Yes, thanks, the computer I'm working on now is a Dell 4600 and the
manual made that clear.

As a rule, I install
the larger capacity memory in the "first" pair of slots.


But is that a personal practice, or maybe a habit left over from fast
vs. slow memory, or is it really based on some benchmark testing or
recommended by engineers or so forth?


IIRC (from an admittedly failing memory), when you mix faster & slower
DIMMs, *all* memory runs at the slower speed (tends to keep things in
sync internally - if you were moving data from faster to slower memory
and tried to use the 2 different speeds, fun might ensue g).


Your brain has not had a parity failure yet. Must be ECC! Correct... Ben
 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
does memory brand really matter? Nate Nagel General 11 September 7th 08 07:12 PM
How much does memory speed matter? Cyde Weys General 6 August 1st 06 02:00 PM
Does Video Memory Size Matter? Carol Fieldus Nvidia Videocards 6 October 31st 03 12:00 PM
Single and double sided DDRs Sam Overclocking AMD Processors 2 October 26th 03 01:04 AM
Does memory bank order matter? Sabyasachi Basu Homebuilt PC's 0 August 18th 03 09:49 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:39 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 HardwareBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.