If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Is this PNY Geforce 6600 GT graphics card defective?
I have an AMD XP 2500+, 1GB DDR333 RAM and a PNY Geforce 6600GT.
When I test out some games with it, the system either reboots, crashes to Windows or hangs. Occasionally artifacts are visible if a lot of light effects are present. Unfortunately, the screenshot button doesn't work in the game so I have not been able to save them. If you guys want to see it then let me know, I'll try to get it with a digital camera. When I tried updating with the latest drivers, I couldn't even get into Windows - just a black screen. I had to use the "Last Known Working Configuration" to get in. Is there a stress test I can download which will show if the card is faulty or not? IIRC although 3DMark stresses the graphics card, it doesn't do so for long, and it doesn't detect if artifacts are present. The results with 3D Mark were dismal, I got less than 1FPS for all the tests. Is this to be expected? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Is this PNY Geforce 6600 GT graphics card defective? (Kony, Paul, other regulars please help)
Hi guys. I have uploaded a picture of my 3D marks sco
http://rapidshare.de/files/27490726/...sults.JPG.html My PSU is an Antec Smartpower 350W PSU. The reboots tend to be preceeded by a freeze of around 10 seconds. One thing strange I noticed about the reboots was that either the keyboard or mouse wouldn't work after the reboot (sometimes both). A total PC power off and restart would fix the problem. The Geforce 6600GT is supposed to require a 300W PSU. I have 1 IDE HDD, 1 DVD+/-RW, 1 PCI/IDE card, 1 PCI Gigabit card and 1 SB Audigy. Please let me know if you think the card is defective. I have a few more days until I lose my right to return the card. If you want me to do any other tests, please let me know too. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Is this PNY Geforce 6600 GT graphics card defective?
On 29 Jul 2006 09:16:47 -0700, "altcomphardware"
wrote: I have an AMD XP 2500+, 1GB DDR333 RAM and a PNY Geforce 6600GT. What motherboard and PSU make AND model? When I test out some games with it, the system either reboots, crashes to Windows or hangs. These are three distinctly different things and probably more than one problem causing them. You need to not lump all games together, take ONE game that is known to work properly with it's newest patches and a 6600GT card, and which video driver (generally I would suggest trying a late 8x.xx series driver, no older and not a 9x.xx series. You might try one of the 3DMark benchmarks too or instead, or looping some benchmark demo... but again it has to be known stable with your hardware and driver, as games are rushed in development and quite a few need patches to work on a lot of hardware. Reinstall DirectX9c. It doesn't matter if you already had it installed... just do it. If it's possible the sound is crashing it, disable the sound or try other sound drivers. Is the CPU or video card overheating? Try to isolate each, run Prime95's Torture Test, large in-place FFTs setting for at least a few hours to see if the CPU produces errors. If it does you must rectify that problem before you can determine whether the video card is ok or not (as mentioned above, you may easily have more than one problem). Occasionally artifacts are visible if a lot of light effects are present. Could be overheating, the driver, power supply, or game bugs. Could even be vaulty or ESD damaged memory on the card but this seems less likely than any of the former possibilities. What video card did your system use previously? Did you try playing any of the same games and did they have any problems if so? Unfortunately, the screenshot button doesn't work in the game so I have not been able to save them. If you guys want to see it then let me know, I'll try to get it with a digital camera. Maybe if other things don't work, this could be useful but for the time being, take a multimeter and measure the PSU voltages under heavy load (like when gaming and running the Prime95 Torture test), or if you don't have a multimeter nor access to one, at least note the system temps reported by software. You might also leave the case open (does it have good airflow??) and point a strong desk fan at the center to see if it resolves anything. When I tried updating with the latest drivers, I couldn't even get into Windows - just a black screen. I had to use the "Last Known Working Configuration" to get in. you didn't even mention the games you're having trouble with but that might be information better suited to a gaming forum where far more people are familiar with problems any particular game might have with or w/o patches, drivers, etc. Is there a stress test I can download which will show if the card is faulty or not? IIRC although 3DMark stresses the graphics card, it doesn't do so for long, and it doesn't detect if artifacts are present. The results with 3D Mark were dismal, I got less than 1FPS for all the tests. Is this to be expected? That seems very odd, to get only 1FPS. I'd wonder if the video card is overheating though instability from bad power would also cause a similar pausing and downclocked speed - lower average performance. Try an older 3DMark, 2001 and 2003. One of not both can be set to loop mode, and by only setting it to run on high detail, the demanding tests, you will keep as much load on the video card as possible, minimize the CPU as a bottleneck... or vice versa, choose low detail and low resolution to put most load on CPU in a 3D environment. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Is this PNY Geforce 6600 GT graphics card defective?
"altcomphardware" wrote in message oups.com... I have an AMD XP 2500+, 1GB DDR333 RAM and a PNY Geforce 6600GT. When I test out some games with it, the system either reboots, crashes to Windows or hangs. Occasionally artifacts are visible if a lot of light effects are present. Unfortunately, the screenshot button doesn't work in the game so I have not been able to save them. If you guys want to see it then let me know, I'll try to get it with a digital camera. When I tried updating with the latest drivers, I couldn't even get into Windows - just a black screen. I had to use the "Last Known Working Configuration" to get in. Is there a stress test I can download which will show if the card is faulty or not? IIRC although 3DMark stresses the graphics card, it doesn't do so for long, and it doesn't detect if artifacts are present. The results with 3D Mark were dismal, I got less than 1FPS for all the tests. Is this to be expected? try the previous offical drivers (as kony suggest) 84.21. they're in the archive section of www.nvidia.com and set AGP speed to 4x (I find 8x to show up graphical glitches though it doesnt crash my machine. fast-writes OFF is also best for stability. and if you mean you've recently changed cards then thoroughly uninstalling the old drivers is a must and it helps to reinstall the motherboard drivers (including the AGP port driver). google for coolbits.reg and use it - it unlocks hidden parts of the display control panel and check your temps - 50s when idling up to 65c when gaming is normal. good luck. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Is this PNY Geforce 6600 GT graphics card defective? (Kony, Paul, other regulars please help)
In article . com,
"altcomphardware" wrote: Hi guys. I have uploaded a picture of my 3D marks sco http://rapidshare.de/files/27490726/...sults.JPG.html My PSU is an Antec Smartpower 350W PSU. The reboots tend to be preceeded by a freeze of around 10 seconds. One thing strange I noticed about the reboots was that either the keyboard or mouse wouldn't work after the reboot (sometimes both). A total PC power off and restart would fix the problem. The Geforce 6600GT is supposed to require a 300W PSU. I have 1 IDE HDD, 1 DVD+/-RW, 1 PCI/IDE card, 1 PCI Gigabit card and 1 SB Audigy. Please let me know if you think the card is defective. I have a few more days until I lose my right to return the card. If you want me to do any other tests, please let me know too. And from your other post, you have "AMD XP 2500+, 1GB DDR333 RAM". One thing missing, is what motherboard you are using. Entry #39 in the table here is beating your pants off :-) By 1356 points to your 269 points. And he is using an "XP 1900+". http://www.techimo.com/forum/t161088.html The very first question is, did you remember to uninstall the drivers for the old video card ? That has caused me grief in the past (so much grief, that in one case the only way I could get a new video card to work right, was an OS reinstall). When the old video card is still in the computer, you uninstall the video driver. Then, you are ready to come up at 640x480 driverless with the new card. Followed by installing whatever minimum DirectX version the new card needs, and the new video card driver. (Assumes the chipset AGP driver is in good shape and is up to date.) The best order of install is AGP chipset driver first, video card driver second, and DirectX can be either before or after or as many times as you like. If the chipset and graphics card drivers were not installed properly, I'd be surprised if 3DMark06 would run properly. It could be that texture acceleration is not enabled. Run Dxdiag from the directx9 install, and see what it reports. (I'd recommend the taskbar options popup of Powerstrip from entechtaiwan.com, but it has a limited trial period now. At least I cannot run it any more.) http://www.windowsresource.net/guides/hardware.php I'll reserve comment on the artifacts, until you are sure the drivers are all in place and everything is working properly. Artifacts can mean the card is bad, with say a lot of blocks or colored squares could mean some bad video card RAM. If the problem is occasional, it could be GPU temperature, and maybe you'd be seeing it as the card gets warmed up by the 3DMark test run. (Does the video card heatsink look solid to you ? Is it tilted or does it look like it is out of place ? I don't know anything about utils that can display GPU temp, but that would be one thing worth checking if you can find a util to do that.) The freeze for 10 seconds, followed by the restart, doesn't sound like a power problem. It sounds like the OS is crashing because of a driver problem or something. Is anything recorded in the Event Viewer ? If you disable automatic restarts on a crash, what info is displayed on the blue screen ? In terms of your hardware power situation, I don't think you are in trouble there. I found a picture of the label on the side of a SmartPower 350W, and you can compare my numbers to what is printed on the label on yours: 3.3@22A 5V@21A 12V1@10A 12V2@15A +5VSB@2A (3.3V&5V power 130W) http://www.endpcnoise.com/cgi-bin/e/...smartpower_350 I have an Nforce2 board with a 3200+ on it, and my measured combined power is about 100W on 3.3V&5V. Which is less than the 130W limit. And my board uses the 5V rail for CPU power. AFAIK, the 6600GT draws 12V@4A in 3D mode, via the motherboard power cable. I think that would be coming from the 10A output (12V1). Again, I don't think you have enough other loads, to exceed the 10A limit. So, you could have a bad card. But first you have to clean uo the software problems. In the interest of time, find a spare hard drive. Disconnect all other hard drives in the system (making notes of where they were connected), get out your Windows install CD, and reinstall. Plop on the drivers from the motherboard CD, which should give you chipset drivers. Install the video card drivers from the video card CD. Now, you can shut down and connect whatever disk has the installer for 3DMark etc. Run Dxdiag and your other tests, and see if things are any different. By using a clean install, you may find that texture acceleration is enabled and your score is better. If you are still seeing artifacts and time is running out, return the card just in case. Who knows how well video card memories are tested... Paul |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Is this PNY Geforce 6600 GT graphics card defective? (Kony, Paul, other regulars please help)
Thanks for helping Paul :-)
Don't know what alt.comp.hardware would be without you & kony :-D And from your other post, you have "AMD XP 2500+, 1GB DDR333 RAM". One thing missing, is what motherboard you are using. Motherboard is an Abit NF7. Entry #39 in the table here is beating your pants off :-) By 1356 points to your 269 points. And he is using an "XP 1900+". http://www.techimo.com/forum/t161088.html How embarassing! The result discrepancy *has* to be due to a problem, right? Not variability between graphics card manufacturers, etc. The very first question is, did you remember to uninstall the drivers for the old video card ? That has caused me grief in the past (so much grief, that in one case the only way I could get a new video card to work right, was an OS reinstall). When the old video card is still in the computer, you uninstall the video driver. Then, you are ready to come up at 640x480 driverless with the new card. Followed by installing whatever minimum DirectX version the new card needs, and the new video card driver. (Assumes the chipset AGP driver is in good shape and is up to date.) The best order of install is AGP chipset driver first, video card driver second, and DirectX can be either before or after or as many times as you like. At first I didn't uninstall the drivers for my old Sapphire Ati Radeon 9800 Pro. It artifacts so badly I can't see anything even in Windows, and my motherboard doesn't have onboard graphics. I have uninstalled it through "Add/Remove Software", but as we all know Windows tends to be quite sloppy in clearing up old files. If the chipset and graphics card drivers were not installed properly, I'd be surprised if 3DMark06 would run properly. It could be that texture acceleration is not enabled. Run Dxdiag from the directx9 install, and see what it reports. (I'd recommend the taskbar options popup of Powerstrip from entechtaiwan.com, but it has a limited trial period now. At least I cannot run it any more.) I will follow your advice later on to try it on a fresh Windows install. http://www.windowsresource.net/guides/hardware.php I'll reserve comment on the artifacts, until you are sure the drivers are all in place and everything is working properly. Artifacts can mean the card is bad, with say a lot of blocks or colored squares could mean some bad video card RAM. The patterns I saw was checkerboarding, with very distinct and well separated squares. If the problem is occasional, it could be GPU temperature, and maybe you'd be seeing it as the card gets warmed up by the 3DMark test run. (Does the video card heatsink look solid to you ? It is asymmetric so it is hard to tell. My Sapphire Radeon 9800 Pro's heatsink moves a *bit* when you push it around, so isn't a bit of give of the heatsink expected? Granted the Radeon was busted, which was why I dared to push the heatsink around. Is it tilted or does it look like it is out of place ? I don't know anything about utils that can display GPU temp, but that would be one thing worth checking if you can find a util to do that.) The freeze for 10 seconds, followed by the restart, doesn't sound like a power problem. It sounds like the OS is crashing because of a driver problem or something. Is anything recorded in the Event Viewer ? If you disable automatic restarts on a crash, what info is displayed on the blue screen ? Faulting application oblivion.exe, version 0.1x, faulting module oblivion.exe, version 0.1x, fault address 0x002c7c2c. In terms of your hardware power situation, I don't think you are in trouble there. I found a picture of the label on the side of a SmartPower 350W, and you can compare my numbers to what is printed on the label on yours: 3.3@22A 5V@21A 12V1@10A 12V2@15A +5VSB@2A (3.3V&5V power 130W) http://www.endpcnoise.com/cgi-bin/e/...smartpower_350 I have an Nforce2 board with a 3200+ on it, and my measured combined power is about 100W on 3.3V&5V. Which is less than the 130W limit. And my board uses the 5V rail for CPU power. AFAIK, the 6600GT draws 12V@4A in 3D mode, via the motherboard power cable. I think that would be coming from the 10A output (12V1). Again, I don't think you have enough other loads, to exceed the 10A limit. So, you could have a bad card. But first you have to clean uo the software problems. In the interest of time, find a spare hard drive. Disconnect all other hard drives in the system (making notes of where they were connected), get out your Windows install CD, and reinstall. Plop on the drivers from the motherboard CD, which should give you chipset drivers. Install the video card drivers from the video card CD. Now, you can shut down and connect whatever disk has the installer for 3DMark etc. Run Dxdiag and your other tests, and see if things are any different. OK, I will try reinstalling Windows. I happen to have a spare 160GB HD around. By using a clean install, you may find that texture acceleration is enabled and your score is better. If you are still seeing artifacts and time is running out, return the card just in case. Who knows how well video card memories are tested... Paul Thanks. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Is this PNY Geforce 6600 GT graphics card defective?
kony wrote: On 29 Jul 2006 09:16:47 -0700, "altcomphardware" wrote: I have an AMD XP 2500+, 1GB DDR333 RAM and a PNY Geforce 6600GT. What motherboard and PSU make AND model? Motherboard is an Abit NF7, PSU Antec Smartpower 350W. When I test out some games with it, the system either reboots, crashes to Windows or hangs. These are three distinctly different things and probably more than one problem causing them. One thing I thought of was that - my Sapphire Radeon 9800 Pro died after I accidentally bumped it on a powered-on system. Could that have triggered a surge that damaged other components? Also, despite changing to a 3200+ rated CPU heatsink, my 2500+ still overheats when I overclock it to 3200+. At the moment, everything is at stock speed and I will be changing the thermal grease, but could a partially damaged CPU due to overclocking be responsible, or would I definitely notice if I had a damaged CPU? Once, after an mobo overheat (75 Celcius) inspired shutdown, the CPU was identified as a 1100+ and not a 2500+! You need to not lump all games together, take ONE game that is known to work properly with it's newest patches and a 6600GT card, and which video driver (generally I would suggest trying a late 8x.xx series driver, no older and not a 9x.xx series. OK, I will do what Paul says - reinstall Windows, then test games like HL2 or Quake 4 or Doom 3 that have been out for a while and known to work with the card. You might try one of the 3DMark benchmarks too or instead, or looping some benchmark demo... but again it has to be known stable with your hardware and driver, as games are rushed in development and quite a few need patches to work on a lot of hardware. Can you recommend any benchmark with a loop feature that I can run for a few hours? Reinstall DirectX9c. It doesn't matter if you already had it installed... just do it. OK, I will do that with my new Windows install. If it's possible the sound is crashing it, disable the sound or try other sound drivers. Hmm, I don't think this is the cause. When my Radeon 9800 Pro was working, Oblivion had the occasional crash but nothing as bad as this. Is the CPU or video card overheating? The CPU is at stock speeds, and my mobo should start beeping when it gets too hot. Try to isolate each, run Prime95's Torture Test, large in-place FFTs setting for at least a few hours to see if the CPU produces errors. If it does you must rectify that problem before you can determine whether the video card is ok or not (as mentioned above, you may easily have more than one problem). OK, will do. Occasionally artifacts are visible if a lot of light effects are present. Could be overheating, the driver, power supply, or game bugs. Could even be vaulty or ESD damaged memory on the card but this seems less likely than any of the former possibilities. I will test out other games on a fresh Windows install. What video card did your system use previously? Did you try playing any of the same games and did they have any problems if so? Sapphire Atlantis Radeon 9800 Pro 128MB. Oblivion had the occasional rare crash (but I understand the game is buggy). Most other games were stable with no problems. Unfortunately, the screenshot button doesn't work in the game so I have not been able to save them. If you guys want to see it then let me know, I'll try to get it with a digital camera. Maybe if other things don't work, this could be useful but for the time being, take a multimeter and measure the PSU voltages under heavy load (like when gaming and running the Prime95 Torture test), or if you don't have a multimeter nor access to one, at least note the system temps reported by software. You might also leave the case open (does it have good airflow??) and point a strong desk fan at the center to see if it resolves anything. Yup. My case has a 16" desk fan cooling it, which is how I bumped the Radeon during operation :-/ That seems very odd, to get only 1FPS. I'd wonder if the video card is overheating though instability from bad power would also cause a similar pausing and downclocked speed - lower average performance. Paul noted my 3DMark 2006 score of ~250 was very low compared to another guy with a slower CPU (1600+ vs 2500+) who got ~1100! So it seems something is definitely amiss. Try an older 3DMark, 2001 and 2003. One of not both can be set to loop mode, and by only setting it to run on high detail, the demanding tests, you will keep as much load on the video card as possible, minimize the CPU as a bottleneck... or vice versa, choose low detail and low resolution to put most load on CPU in a 3D environment. OK. I'll try that. BRB after a couple of hours, it looks like I have my afternoon mapped out :-( |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Is this PNY Geforce 6600 GT graphics card defective?
Sleepy wrote: "altcomphardware" wrote in message oups.com... I have an AMD XP 2500+, 1GB DDR333 RAM and a PNY Geforce 6600GT. When I test out some games with it, the system either reboots, crashes to Windows or hangs. Occasionally artifacts are visible if a lot of light effects are present. Unfortunately, the screenshot button doesn't work in the game so I have not been able to save them. If you guys want to see it then let me know, I'll try to get it with a digital camera. When I tried updating with the latest drivers, I couldn't even get into Windows - just a black screen. I had to use the "Last Known Working Configuration" to get in. Is there a stress test I can download which will show if the card is faulty or not? IIRC although 3DMark stresses the graphics card, it doesn't do so for long, and it doesn't detect if artifacts are present. The results with 3D Mark were dismal, I got less than 1FPS for all the tests. Is this to be expected? try the previous offical drivers (as kony suggest) 84.21. they're in the archive section of www.nvidia.com and set AGP speed to 4x (I find 8x to show up graphical glitches though it doesnt crash my machine. fast-writes OFF is also best for stability. and if you mean you've recently changed cards then thoroughly uninstalling the old drivers is a must and it helps to reinstall the motherboard drivers (including the AGP port driver). google for coolbits.reg and use it - it unlocks hidden parts of the display control panel and check your temps - 50s when idling up to 65c when gaming is normal. good luck. Thanks sleepy. I'm off to reinstall Windows. Luckily I have a backup (if slow) computer so I won't be bored in the meantime :-) |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Is this PNY Geforce 6600 GT graphics card defective?
On 30 Jul 2006 04:16:42 -0700, "altcomphardware"
wrote: kony wrote: On 29 Jul 2006 09:16:47 -0700, "altcomphardware" wrote: I have an AMD XP 2500+, 1GB DDR333 RAM and a PNY Geforce 6600GT. What motherboard and PSU make AND model? Motherboard is an Abit NF7, PSU Antec Smartpower 350W. When I test out some games with it, the system either reboots, crashes to Windows or hangs. These are three distinctly different things and probably more than one problem causing them. One thing I thought of was that - my Sapphire Radeon 9800 Pro died after I accidentally bumped it on a powered-on system. Could that have triggered a surge that damaged other components? To clarify, you mean that you bumped that system, and have thus far only replaced the seemingly dead Radeon 9800 Pro? If so, yes you may have damaged the AGP slot or something else but I don't know what else. problem is we have too many variables now, it would be good to test the card in another system if possible, but even then it's not certain whether you have a software (OS, driver or game) or hardware (motherboard probably, or maybe PSU, the new card does use more power, IIRC). Also, despite changing to a 3200+ rated CPU heatsink, What heatsink? Lots of lower-end sinks (even some that aren't priced so low) are rated a bit higher than realistically capable. However, you're overclocking, there are more variables involved. You'll just have to keep it at stock speed till you can isolate the variable causing the instability. my 2500+ still overheats when I overclock it to 3200+. The same rules for cooling still apply, decent sink, decent thermal interface, decent chassis cooling... and not overvolting it much unless you have a really good 'sink. At the moment, everything is at stock speed and I will be changing the thermal grease, but could a partially damaged CPU due to overclocking be responsible, or would I definitely notice if I had a damaged CPU? How hot was it getting? Generally, if it was only getting hot enough to crash for awhile, it's probably fine. I've taken apart systems where the junk silicone thermal grease had degraded till there was a dark brown spot on the back of the CPU and after fixing the cooling problem, it then ran fine... but I didn't try overclocking it, this was someone else's system. You can't really determine "definitely notice" it until you first make sure it never gets too hot. The higher the speed, (especially overclocking), the lower the stable temp will be. You can raise the voltage slightly to offset this, and indeed it could be necessary to raise voltage on a Xp2500 to get it around 3200 and beyond, but with it overheating already, it'd just run that much hotter... so you have to keep it cool as-is first, and by doing so, you also reduce the voltage it'll need for any given speed. Once, after an mobo overheat (75 Celcius) inspired shutdown, the CPU was identified as a 1100+ and not a 2500+! Not a big deal, the bios may do that - default to the lowest FSB speed. it shouldn't be over 75C though, I'd have taken the 'sink off long ago and reapplied thermal compound, remounted it. Also confirm that it is running at the correct voltage. You need to not lump all games together, take ONE game that is known to work properly with it's newest patches and a 6600GT card, and which video driver (generally I would suggest trying a late 8x.xx series driver, no older and not a 9x.xx series. OK, I will do what Paul says - reinstall Windows, then test games like HL2 or Quake 4 or Doom 3 that have been out for a while and known to work with the card. Considering the overheat issues, I'd probably open the case and point a fan at it first, and remount the heatsink. We know it's not overheating due to windows, so you might as well take care of the known problem first then see what other problems remain once it's running cool enough. However, if it has been running too long long term, you could have all kinds of data corruption but it seems unlikely if you only have these crashes/reboots/etc in games. That is the case, yes? Only problems while gaming, never any other time? You might try one of the 3DMark benchmarks too or instead, or looping some benchmark demo... but again it has to be known stable with your hardware and driver, as games are rushed in development and quite a few need patches to work on a lot of hardware. Can you recommend any benchmark with a loop feature that I can run for a few hours? 3Dmark2001 will, I don't recall about 2003. Reinstall DirectX9c. It doesn't matter if you already had it installed... just do it. OK, I will do that with my new Windows install. If it's possible the sound is crashing it, disable the sound or try other sound drivers. Hmm, I don't think this is the cause. When my Radeon 9800 Pro was working, Oblivion had the occasional crash but nothing as bad as this. Is the CPU or video card overheating? The CPU is at stock speeds, and my mobo should start beeping when it gets too hot. You should be able to keep that CPU under 60C (actually significantly lower with a good heatsink) unless your computer room is sweltering hot. You might also leave the case open (does it have good airflow??) and point a strong desk fan at the center to see if it resolves anything. Yup. My case has a 16" desk fan cooling it, which is how I bumped the Radeon during operation :-/ Pointing into the case? If so, you should definitely remount the heatsink, the CPU should never be getting up to 75C. Now a stange thought- is it possible your motherboard is reporting the wrong temp, and unnecessarily rebooting the system due to this misreported temp though it might not actually be that hot? It wouldn't account for all the problems, but I still suspect you might have more than one cause. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Is this PNY Geforce 6600 GT graphics card defective?
Hi Kony. Looks like you all were right; old graphics card drivers were
part of the problem. A fresh Windows install seemed to improve 3D Mark scores and remove the hangs/reboots. However, my 3D Mark 2006 scores are still slightly underperforming (another guy with a AMD XP 1600+ got ~1300 IIRC; see Paul's post) and it is still artifacting. I will test it out with other games tonight and see if it is just Oblivion that is causing problems. Check out: http://rapidshare.de/files/27578520/...blems.JPG.html 1247 3D Marks with version 2006. I have taken some digital photos of the artifacts in Oblivion in the bottom right corner. The right picture has wierd-shaped artifacts because my shield arm went up and refreshed the view :-/ To clarify, you mean that you bumped that system, and have thus far only replaced the seemingly dead Radeon 9800 Pro? Yes. If so, yes you may have damaged the AGP slot or something else but I don't know what else. problem is we have too many variables now, it would be good to test the card in another system if possible, but even then it's not certain whether you have a software (OS, driver or game) or hardware (motherboard probably, or maybe PSU, the new card does use more power, IIRC). OK it is possible there are other problems, or I might have gotten lucky. A reinstall of Windows seemed to help. I will test it out with other games tonight and see if there are any other problems. Will also download 3D Mark 2001 and do a continuous loop. Also, despite changing to a 3200+ rated CPU heatsink, What heatsink? Lots of lower-end sinks (even some that aren't priced so low) are rated a bit higher than realistically capable. However, you're overclocking, there are more variables involved. You'll just have to keep it at stock speed till you can isolate the variable causing the instability. Crap! I didn't know coolers are like PSUs which rate higher than reality. I thought WYSIWYG. This is a Speeze cooler. http://www.ebuyer.com/UK/product/87736 my 2500+ still overheats when I overclock it to 3200+. The same rules for cooling still apply, decent sink, decent thermal interface, decent chassis cooling... and not overvolting it much unless you have a really good 'sink. I'm guessing it is the thermal grease. It is a few years old (reused, just scraped around the CPU die and slapped back on). At the moment, everything is at stock speed and I will be changing the thermal grease, but could a partially damaged CPU due to overclocking be responsible, or would I definitely notice if I had a damaged CPU? How hot was it getting? Generally, if it was only getting hot enough to crash for awhile, it's probably fine. I've taken apart systems where the junk silicone thermal grease had degraded till there was a dark brown spot on the back of the CPU and after fixing the cooling problem, it then ran fine... but I didn't try overclocking it, this was someone else's system. You can't really determine "definitely notice" it until you first make sure it never gets too hot. The higher the speed, (especially overclocking), the lower the stable temp will be. You can raise the voltage slightly to offset this, and indeed it could be necessary to raise voltage on a Xp2500 to get it around 3200 and beyond, but with it overheating already, it'd just run that much hotter... so you have to keep it cool as-is first, and by doing so, you also reduce the voltage it'll need for any given speed. The voltage to get it to work at 3200+ was 1.8V. Otherwise at 2500+ is was the stock voltage for a Barton. (can't remember exactly) Once, after an mobo overheat (75 Celcius) inspired shutdown, the CPU was identified as a 1100+ and not a 2500+! Not a big deal, the bios may do that - default to the lowest FSB speed. it shouldn't be over 75C though, I'd have taken the 'sink off long ago and reapplied thermal compound, remounted it. Also confirm that it is running at the correct voltage. You need to not lump all games together, take ONE game that is known to work properly with it's newest patches and a 6600GT card, and which video driver (generally I would suggest trying a late 8x.xx series driver, no older and not a 9x.xx series. OK, I will do what Paul says - reinstall Windows, then test games like HL2 or Quake 4 or Doom 3 that have been out for a while and known to work with the card. Considering the overheat issues, I'd probably open the case and point a fan at it first, and remount the heatsink. We know it's not overheating due to windows, so you might as well take care of the known problem first then see what other problems remain once it's running cool enough. However, if it has been running too long long term, you could have all kinds of data corruption but it seems unlikely if you only have these crashes/reboots/etc in games. That is the case, yes? Only problems while gaming, never any other time? Yes. The problems were only in games. I only ever play FPS games. Now and then when I still had the Radeon I'd get freezes in Doom 3 or sudden exits in Oblivion. Since reinstalling Windows and the drivers, and replacing the Radeon 9800 with the Geforce 6600, I get artifacts. I will test out other FPS games for freezes. You might try one of the 3DMark benchmarks too or instead, or looping some benchmark demo... but again it has to be known stable with your hardware and driver, as games are rushed in development and quite a few need patches to work on a lot of hardware. Can you recommend any benchmark with a loop feature that I can run for a few hours? 3Dmark2001 will, I don't recall about 2003. 2003 doesn't at least with the demo version (just tested it). Reinstall DirectX9c. It doesn't matter if you already had it installed... just do it. OK, I will do that with my new Windows install. If it's possible the sound is crashing it, disable the sound or try other sound drivers. Hmm, I don't think this is the cause. When my Radeon 9800 Pro was working, Oblivion had the occasional crash but nothing as bad as this. Is the CPU or video card overheating? The CPU is at stock speeds, and my mobo should start beeping when it gets too hot. You should be able to keep that CPU under 60C (actually significantly lower with a good heatsink) unless your computer room is sweltering hot. Room temp is currently 26.8 Celcius. You might also leave the case open (does it have good airflow??) and point a strong desk fan at the center to see if it resolves anything. Yup. My case has a 16" desk fan cooling it, which is how I bumped the Radeon during operation :-/ Pointing into the case? If so, you should definitely remount the heatsink, the CPU should never be getting up to 75C. Now a stange thought- is it possible your motherboard is reporting the wrong temp, and unnecessarily rebooting the system due to this misreported temp though it might not actually be that hot? It wouldn't account for all the problems, but I still suspect you might have more than one cause. Yeah, I suspect I have more than one cause myself. I'm OK not overclocking my CPU for now, so I won't be getting some good new thermal grease. When I do buy more stuff, I'll slap on some thermal grease on the order and see how it goes. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Graphics card & LCD monitor died together... | [email protected] | General | 2 | July 23rd 06 09:15 PM |
nVidia drivers for Suse | No one | Nvidia Videocards | 9 | May 11th 05 01:09 PM |
GARY HEADLEE Motherboard and Video Card Repair | neilslade | General | 8 | March 1st 05 02:59 AM |
Won't Post with GeForce Fx 5200 graphics card | TC | Homebuilt PC's | 6 | April 20th 04 06:32 PM |
A graphics card with video capture | Hupjack | Homebuilt PC's | 14 | April 7th 04 09:15 PM |