If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Worth writing zeros to my used hard drives?
Home user with XP Pro.
I bought some 160 GB hard drives a couple of years ago and they got filled up with data. I have now migrated all the data off these 160 GB hard drives and will now use the drives to hold backups. QUESTION --- As the HDDs are now empty is it worth writing zeros, before using them again, in order to force the HDD to map out any defective sectors? QUESTION -- Or will mapping out of any defective sectors happen automatically when any bad sectors are next written to, which means it is not worth writing the zeros? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Worth writing zeros to my used hard drives?
Jax wrote
Home user with XP Pro. I bought some 160 GB hard drives a couple of years ago and they got filled up with data. I have now migrated all the data off these 160 GB hard drives and will now use the drives to hold backups. I wouldnt bother myself, I'd just get another 250-500G drive to hold backups. QUESTION --- As the HDDs are now empty is it worth writing zeros, before using them again, in order to force the HDD to map out any defective sectors? Nope, it shouldnt have developed any and should be discarded if it has. QUESTION -- Or will mapping out of any defective sectors happen automatically when any bad sectors are next written to, Yes. which means it is not worth writing the zeros? Correct. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Worth writing zeros to my used hard drives?
"Jax" wrote in message
Home user with XP Pro. I bought some 160 GB hard drives a couple of years ago and they got filled up with data. I have now migrated all the data off these 160 GB hard drives and will now use the drives to hold backups. QUESTION --- As the HDDs are now empty is it worth writing zeros, before using them again, in order to force the HDD to map out any defective sectors? QUESTION -- Or will mapping out of any defective sectors happen automatically when any bad sectors are next written to, which means it is not worth writing the zeros? Ah, a question that can only be asked if you know what the answer is. Smart one. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Worth writing zeros to my used hard drives?
Jax writes:
QUESTION --- As the HDDs are now empty is it worth writing zeros, before using them again, in order to force the HDD to map out any defective sectors? I'd say write over the drive and use the SMART interface to detect whether the HDD finds any bad sectors. If it does, replace the drive. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Worth writing zeros to my used hard drives?
You do not have to write out zero's on them.
-- DaveW ___________ "Jax" wrote in message ... Home user with XP Pro. I bought some 160 GB hard drives a couple of years ago and they got filled up with data. I have now migrated all the data off these 160 GB hard drives and will now use the drives to hold backups. QUESTION --- As the HDDs are now empty is it worth writing zeros, before using them again, in order to force the HDD to map out any defective sectors? QUESTION -- Or will mapping out of any defective sectors happen automatically when any bad sectors are next written to, which means it is not worth writing the zeros? |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Worth writing zeros to my used hard drives?
"Paul Rubin" wrote in message
Jax writes: QUESTION --- As the HDDs are now empty is it worth writing zeros, before using them again, in order to force the HDD to map out any defective sectors? I'd say write over the drive and use the SMART interface to detect whether the HDD finds any bad sectors. Nonsense, aren't you a regular here? You don't need to do that to 'find' any. Bad sectors that are to be reassigned by writes will already be known as candidate bad sectors and logged as such under "Current Pending Sector Count". If there aren't any, none will be reas- signed by writing. To detect any new you need to read the drive, not write it. If it does, replace the drive. Yup, who cares whether the cause is external. You just keep replacing them until you get a clue. Good for business, no. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Worth writing zeros to my used hard drives?
"Folkert Rienstra" writes:
I'd say write over the drive and use the SMART interface to detect whether the HDD finds any bad sectors. Nonsense, aren't you a regular here? You don't need to do that to 'find' any. Bad sectors that are to be reassigned by writes will already be known as candidate bad sectors and logged as such under "Current Pending Sector Count". If there aren't any, none will be reas- signed by writing. To detect any new you need to read the drive, not write it. These drives apparently hadn't been in use (or at least written to) for a while. It is possible that bad sectors developed while the drive was sitting on the shelf. I've certainly taken working drives out of service, then had them fail when I tried using them a year or two later. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Worth writing zeros to my used hard drives?
On Mar 13, 3:14 pm, Jax wrote:
Home user with XP Pro. I bought some 160 GB hard drives a couple of years ago and they got filled up with data. I have now migrated all the data off these 160 GB hard drives and will now use the drives to hold backups. QUESTION --- As the HDDs are now empty is it worth writing zeros, before using them again, in order to force the HDD to map out any defective sectors? QUESTION -- Or will mapping out of any defective sectors happen automatically when any bad sectors are next written to, which means it is not worth writing the zeros? It's worth zeroing the data on the drives under two circumstances. 1) You're selling them, and don't want any one to steal your bank account info, etc. 2) You don't want anyone to see your porn collection If it has bad sectors, replace the unit. According to a very recent google study of over 100,000 consumer grade hard drives, those with read errors were 39 times more likely to fail within 60 days than those without. It's worth checking the drive for bad sectors. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Worth writing zeros to my used hard drives?
wrote in message oups.com
On Mar 13, 3:14 pm, Jax wrote: Home user with XP Pro. I bought some 160 GB hard drives a couple of years ago and they got filled up with data. I have now migrated all the data off these 160 GB hard drives and will now use the drives to hold backups. QUESTION --- As the HDDs are now empty is it worth writing zeros, before using them again, in order to force the HDD to map out any defective sectors? QUESTION -- Or will mapping out of any defective sectors happen automatically when any bad sectors are next written to, which means it is not worth writing the zeros? It's worth zeroing the data on the drives under two circumstances. 1) You're selling them, and don't want any one to steal your bank account info, etc. 2) You don't want anyone to see your porn collection If it has bad sectors, replace the unit. According to a very recent google study of over 100,000 consumer grade hard drives, those with read errors were 39 times more likely to fail within 60 days than those without. Which says absolutely nothing if those without don't fail, now is it. And the exact phrase was: "After the first scan error, drives are 39 times more like- ly to fail within 60 days than drives without scan errors." Unfortunately there is no such thing as a 'scan error'. Your 'read' errors appear under probational counts. "The critical threshold for probational counts is also one: after the first event, drives are 16 times more likely to fail within 60 days than drives with zero probational counts." There were other inconsistencies in the report as well, like lower risk numbers for the total lifetime (longer than 60 days). They also didn't say what they considered a failure and whether the 'failed' drives actually failed in a different system once replaced. Neither did they check whether it was the system killing the drives. It's worth checking the drive for bad sectors. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Worth writing zeros to my used hard drives?
In comp.sys.ibm.pc.hardware.storage Jax wrote:
Home user with XP Pro. I bought some 160 GB hard drives a couple of years ago and they got filled up with data. I have now migrated all the data off these 160 GB hard drives and will now use the drives to hold backups. QUESTION --- As the HDDs are now empty is it worth writing zeros, before using them again, in order to force the HDD to map out any defective sectors? Not really needed, since if you write new data, this will happen anyways. QUESTION -- Or will mapping out of any defective sectors happen automatically when any bad sectors are next written to, which means it is not worth writing the zeros? It will. But you may want to run a long SMART selftest to find weak sectors before using the disks. Arno |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Worth writing zeros to my used hard drives? | Jax | General | 17 | March 16th 07 03:47 AM |
These old drives are just not worth it | Football Nut | Storage (alternative) | 22 | March 11th 05 08:55 PM |
external hard drives & cd-writing | travis | Storage (alternative) | 0 | February 24th 05 01:58 PM |
Hard drive writing detection | Fred | General Hardware | 0 | April 15th 04 07:50 PM |
HP 5si page count zeros when turned off | GTO69RA4 | Printers | 1 | June 27th 03 03:45 AM |