If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
On Sat, 19 Jun 2004 21:50:13 +0000 (UTC), Rich
wrote: -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Hi I'm currently thinking about making myself a standalone FTP server. The main problem I'm trying to get around is the noise. I can't afford to get all special quiet add ons so was thinking of getting an old 486 and sticking it in the cupboard. It's asking for trouble to place any system in an enclosed area. You didn't make clear that the cupboard is enclosed, but thought I'd go ahead and mention it. Today the choices for quiet systems, providing you don't use something post-Athlon era, are many. Today's dirt-cheap low-end socket A coolers, when paired with a very low RPM fan (whether it be a different than stock fan or on a fan controller, an adapter to reduce voltage or 7 or 5V, or whatever the method) can be an inaudible way to cool anything socket 7 or 370, up to a Tualatin 1.5GHz... it is not necessary to go with such an old system that due to it's age the reliability is questionable, the performance quite low (including network performance, drive performance and size support, memory capacity, etc, etc). IMHO, the sweet spot for such a system would be a Pentium 3 700, in a Via 694X motherboard. It gives modern enough support for fast networking, over a GB of memory, ATA66 to 100, and some have 48LBA support for large drives, plus USB, AGP Universal slot, etc. Alternatively there's the Via Eden and similar platforms, also low heat and many need no heatsink fan. - From my memory the 486 had no computer fan apart from the power supply and so should be quieter. As the 486 BIOS will not accept a 80 Gig harddrive I'm looking at getting a USB 2 PCI card and using an external case for it. Quiet isn't necessarily about number of fans, but how fast you run each fan and the type of fan. For example, a Panaflo L1A (in whichever size the application calls for) is very quiet to start with but certainly inaudbile at 7V. A simple, low-part count system that doesn't use a lot of power, create a lot of heat, can also have a Panaflo fan used in the power supply. In other words, a Tualatin 1.5GHz (or other Via, or Coppermine based Intel Celeron or P3) based system with an undervolted Panaflo on the heatsink and another Panaflo in the power supply, can easily be quieter than a 486 box with only the original fan in the power supply. 486 boxes do not have PCI 2.1 support for USB2 cards, the performance should be incredibly poor if it works at all. The external enclosuer, if providing adequate cooling for the drive, may also create a significant amount of noise. Given that the system will be on, presumably 24/7, the long-term effects of high temp might be more pronounced, or rather, the lifespan limitation from elevated temps is sooner reached. IMHO, the last part you want to fail is the hard drive unless you're also making regular backups, which of course you should but it doesn't always happen as we see time and time again from various posts. Any one got any experience on installing a PCI USB card on a 486 computer? Someone has mentioned to me that a lot of 486 used an old version of the PCI format and so USB 2 card maynot work??? LOL, I should read ahead more often. I do have a spare AMD 850 but its noisy as hell and I do not want to leave my quiet laptop on all the time. Most any box can be quiet enough to be inaudible providing you start out with something creating only modest heat, use medium to large CPU heatsink, low-powered video card, and the right fans. Other good candidates for low noise: K6-2 or -3 underclocked (& undervolted if possible) Celeron 300-400, PII-400, Celeron 900 (Tualatin), Celeron 533-800 (Coppermine) Integrated Video ATI Rage Pro Video (doesn't even need a heatsink on GPU). Liquid-bearing hard drives IMHO, your target platform should be at least new enough to support AGP video... even if you don't want/need AGP video, that is a time when OTHER features like PCI support, UATA, USB, larger memory support, etc, were implemented and matured enough to be viable.... even if you did end up adding a USB2 or PCI ATA card. Also keep in mind that with ACPI OS support the CPU will run pretty cool, the peak power and heat radiation as per manufacturer specs will be greatly reduced while CPU is sitting idle, as it would be over 90% of the time. A Celeron 566 would not need a fan on the heatsink at all in this 90% idle situation, for example, but it would be good to put the very low RPM fan on the 'sink just in case a problem arose, like an OS error that puts CPU in a busy loop. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Sounds like it'll be baking in the cupboard. I give it about 3 days max...
"Rich" wrote in message ... -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Hi I'm currently thinking about making myself a standalone FTP server. The main problem I'm trying to get around is the noise. I can't afford to get all special quiet add ons so was thinking of getting an old 486 and sticking it in the cupboard. - From my memory the 486 had no computer fan apart from the power supply and so should be quieter. As the 486 BIOS will not accept a 80 Gig harddrive I'm looking at getting a USB 2 PCI card and using an external case for it. Any one got any experience on installing a PCI USB card on a 486 computer? Someone has mentioned to me that a lot of 486 used an old version of the PCI format and so USB 2 card maynot work??? I do have a spare AMD 850 but its noisy as hell and I do not want to leave my quiet laptop on all the time. Thanks. Rich -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: PGP 8.0.3 iQA/AwUBQNS1EMjtolcV0LnqEQJVNQCg6EFuGEDV7C5pCGoMFyq8ph EoxRYAn0/b cq765D0SYvFEcWRz/nJCPSLv =w3nX -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
On Sat, 19 Jun 2004 23:22:28 -0200, Juhan Leemet
wrote: IMHO, your target platform should be at least new enough to support AGP video... even if you don't want/need AGP video... Huh? What does AGP have to do with these requirements? I bought a relatively new HP just a couple of years ago without AGP (unless you count built in Intel graphics?). Many integrated mobos did not have AGP socket. AGP video, not AGP socket.... as I mentioned, that was not for the feature or performance of the video, but an indicator of the age of the chipset... in other words, I could've tried to list every possible chipset made that supports AGP, or all those that don't, but far simplier to just mention it that way. Integrated motherboards without an AGP slot may still use AGP video. Any motherboard with video via a northbridge chip is using AGP video. Any motherboard with a separate chip "could" be using AGP, as it was a transition for a while, but more often PCI, before the Pentium 2 era. My impression is that mass storage via USB or firewire is a relatively new (and therefore expensive) solution. It's not bad, maybe $20-40 for the enclosure, another $15-30 for the card if the board doesn't support the interface, but certainly slower than ATA33 for USB or ATA66 vs firewire. Even so it doesn't seem to meet the requirement for low noise unless the drive runs hot, and is just an unnecessary complexity and expense. BTW, I'm a bit biased, but I would recomend running Linux (or some other *nix) and serving up files (and providing other useful services) using NFS or Samba (SMB workalike). Works great for me. YMMV Yep, that's a good idea for described use, no point to windows unless it's necessary, or the learning curve is too steep... really no point in spending hours trying to tacking a new OS just to get an FTP server going, though these days there are probably a lot of micro distros pretty much ready to roll. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Rich wrote:
I'm currently thinking about making myself a standalone FTP server. The main problem I'm trying to get around is the noise. I can't afford to get all special quiet add ons so was thinking of getting an old 486 and sticking it in the cupboard. - From my memory the 486 had no computer fan apart from the power supply and so should be quieter. As the 486 BIOS will not accept a 80 Gig harddrive I'm looking at getting a USB 2 PCI card and using an external case for it. You don't need all that. I have an 80 mHz 486, no fans, with a bios that locks up trying to boot an over 8 GB disk, and even then won't access more than 4 GB. The solution is a baby card that intercepts and installs it's own HD bios, and leaves the rest alone. This is available in both ISA and PCI format (or was a couple of years ago). I forget the firms name, and nothing shows up here except at boot time, and I forget where in ROM space the system is set to install itself. At any rate, once installed I believe it can handle something like 137 MB drives. The card is tiny - about 4 by 1 inch (10 x 3 cm). There is, and always has been, a standard bootup installation of added bios software. No need to flash anything. If you remove the card, the machine goes right back to the original configuration. IIRC the card cost about $40, and handles 4 IDE drives. No wiring changes needed. -- fix (vb.): 1. to paper over, obscure, hide from public view; 2. to work around, in a way that produces unintended consequences that are worse than the original problem. Usage: "Windows ME fixes many of the shortcomings of Windows 98 SE". - Hutchison |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
"Rich" wrote in message ... -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Hi I'm currently thinking about making myself a standalone FTP server. The main problem I'm trying to get around is the noise. I can't afford to get all special quiet add ons so was thinking of getting an old 486 and sticking it in the cupboard. - From my memory the 486 had no computer fan apart from the power supply and so should be quieter. As the 486 BIOS will not accept a 80 Gig harddrive I'm looking at getting a USB 2 PCI card and using an external case for it. Any one got any experience on installing a PCI USB card on a 486 computer? Someone has mentioned to me that a lot of 486 used an old version of the PCI format and so USB 2 card maynot work??? I do have a spare AMD 850 but its noisy as hell and I do not want to leave my quiet laptop on all the time. heck, i'd just underclock your amd-850 and use a low speed cooling fan |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
On Sat, 19 Jun 2004 21:50:13 +0000 (UTC), Rich
wrote: -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Hi I'm currently thinking about making myself a standalone FTP server. The main problem I'm trying to get around is the noise. I can't afford to get all special quiet add ons so was thinking of getting an old 486 and sticking it in the cupboard. - From my memory the 486 had no computer fan apart from the power supply and so should be quieter. As the 486 BIOS will not accept a 80 Gig harddrive I'm looking at getting a USB 2 PCI card and using an external case for it. Any one got any experience on installing a PCI USB card on a 486 computer? Someone has mentioned to me that a lot of 486 used an old version of the PCI format and so USB 2 card maynot work??? I do have a spare AMD 850 but its noisy as hell and I do not want to leave my quiet laptop on all the time. Thanks. Rich Instead of fighting with a system that will be too slow for what you want to do, and probably won't support the PCI usb 2.0 card (haven't ran across a 486 motherboard that supported PCI 2.0 spec, which all current PCI cards are) get one of the low powered, fanless Mini-itx systems with a VIA processor onboard. Will be quieter and use less power than a 486, and will work with current hard drives and other peripherils. JT |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
understanding processor speed | Shdyldy | General | 9 | May 13th 04 01:05 AM |
Promise S150 SX4 hangs whole system during system boot (POST)... Plz help! | Morten | General | 1 | March 4th 04 11:39 PM |
Dual processor system vs Single processor system | HawkEye_42 | General | 3 | January 27th 04 11:01 AM |
Dual Vs. Single Processor System | Darren Harris | General | 5 | January 10th 04 11:04 PM |
Multi-boot Windows XP without special software | Timothy Daniels | General | 11 | December 12th 03 05:38 AM |