Once upon a time on usenet ~misfit~ wrote:
Once upon a time on usenet Paul wrote:
~misfit~ wrote:
Has anyone done this? My beloved Dell 2007FP (20" 4:3 UXGA
[1600x1200] IPS) monitor is getting dim. I've been having to use it
on full
brightness for a while now and even then it's not bright and takes a
while to reach
full brightness, maybe 15 seconds.

I'm not rich but could swing a few hundred for a new monitor if I
absolutely had to. However I've been spoiled with this monitor and
nothing that
I can afford even comes close to being as good. I've got a
multimeter, soldering iron and more than half a brain and would
much prefer to keep this
montior out of a landfill.

I've seen a few kits for sale to do the job (this is a cheap one
http://www.aliexpress.com/item/15-23...252220243.html
) but would feel better knowing that someone else here had
successfully done this mod. Also I'm concerned that, as IPS monitors
don't transmit as
much light as TN monitors I might need a brighter than usual
backlight. Thoughts?

I'd stick with replacing with "like" technology.

The trouble with that is CCFL is pretty ancient tech which hasn't
been used in new monitors for a while now. Add to that the fact that
I'm a bit of an 'LED evangelist', an early adopter who has been
running all LED home lighting and have converted my car to all
(except headlights) LEDs. Also CCFLs have a finite lifespan which is
very short when compared with LEDs and it would be nice to fix this
problem once only. I'd like to be able to run these monitors for a
long time yet (I have two of them, my spare isn't quite so dim). So I
figured replace the backlights with LEDs and while I'm in there check
out the condition of the electrolytic capacitors.
But.....

And that's assuming there is actually an inverter or CCFL problem,
and not a problem with the PWM control signal or the power supply.

Odds are, it is an inverter/CCFL problem, with inverters being the
highest probability of failure.

The panel uses multiple CCFL tubes and multiple
inverters. A big panel might use four inverters and
sixteen tubes for example. Now, consider the failure
possibilities. If one CCFL tube turns brown before
the others, you'd notice a non-uniform display. Or,
if one inverter failed, a quadrant of the screen
would go dim. Given such a situation, is the
entire panel going dim ? Would all the inverters
"go on vacation" at the same time ? Unlikely.

Common points of failure, would be the PWM signal
(pulse width modulation, 200Hz, high for 66 cycles,
low for 134 cycles would be 33% intensity setting).
Or, perhaps the 12V power source feeding the inverters
is out of spec. If that was the case, maybe other
circuitry would suffer as well. There have been
monitors with poorly design supplies, power supplies
with leaking electrolytic capacitors. It would be
a shame to waste $100 on LED kits, only to find
the problem was a bad power supply.

Hmmm. The brightness still works, albeit only going from dim to
dimmer so I hope the PWM circuitry is still fine. It was always my
intent to check the PSU when I have it open. I do have the backup
monitor on my second desktop computer but that's used at least weekly
by a friend who visits for gaming session so I'd like to keep
downtime to less than that.
I didn't realise there could be so many tubes. That's what you get for
estimating I suppose. My 15" UXGA IPS laptop screen has a single tube
so, knowing that desktop monitors often have tubes on two sides of
the screen I figured two tubes or perhaps two pairs of tubes as it's
not *that* much bigger than my laptop screen and they're both UXGA.

I heartily recommend repairing things, where you
can "bound" the repair cost, and see ways of
preventing the repair bill from shooting too high.
Obviously, it's a personal judgment call, as to
how far to push this. If the monitor cost $1000,
I might consider making two repair attempts (CCFL
first, LEDs later if the CCFL didn't work out
for some reason). If the monitor cost $300, I'd
probably just bin it.

Those LED kits don't seem to have a diffuser in
evidence. How will the "ripple" in light intensity
from all those point sources be handled ? Will
the panel look like a "cheese grater" when displaying
an all-white background ?

I wondered about that and thought that, if there's room I'd put two
rows of LEDs in each CCFL 'gully', staggered a few millimeters so
that the light is uniform, even arranging them in a V shape if it's
tight....
The very last thing you want, is a repair job
where you're "reminded" every time you look
at the monitor, that you've fouled things up :-)
I know that feeling (the less than perfect repair).

How very true, I've done that before myself also.

Thanks Paul, you've given me some things to think about. I guess next
step is to swap the brighter one to my desk and open the other one up
and have a look-see. Fingers crossed that opening them isn't too hard!

Then again I could always procrastinate longer, keep turning the
lights out and drawing the curtain when I want to game. (I only use
my desktops for gaming, the rest of my computing needs are amply met
by my well-specced T60 ThinkPad.)

Well I've found more info on these excellent monitors online since replying.
Apparently there are *six* CCFLs, three at the top and three at the bottom.
Also apparently the most likely cause of what I'm seeing is a big cap in
stage one of the PSU - a 180uF / 450v electrolytic that's the most common
weak point in these monitors.

A guy who replaced the cap in his said it looks like they'd be a good
candidate for an LED conversion but he was unable to isolate the soft menu
OSD brightness signal and needed to get his back together so didn't have
time to do it then. I wonder if I could use three of those LED kits
(staggering emmiters so they overlap) and add a physical PWM module for
brightness and mount it somehow? Something like http://www.dx.com/p/379683
perhaps?

Unfortunately I couldn't find the lead pitch and available space for a
replacement cap specified anywhere (or pictures to work that out) so I could
order one before pulling the monitor down. :-/ It seems they're a very
tightly joined screwless case that is a chalenge to anyone opening them. I
hope my plastic hasn't got brittle.
--
Shaun.

"Humans will have advanced a long, long way when religious belief has a cozy
little classification in the DSM*."
David Melville (in r.a.s.f1)
(*Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders)